King Mosiah‘s proposal to abolish kingship rule among the people in the land of Zarahemla follows on the heels of his four sons’ renouncement of their kingship claims in order to go among the Lamanites to preach the gospel (Mosiah 29:1-6). While a number of factors might have been involved (King Noah for example),* John Tvedtnes notes that the reasons Mosiah subsequently gave his people for abolishing the monarchy did not always have a clear precedent in Nephite history. In fact, Mosiah’s reasons appear to have been influenced to a good extent by his knowledge of Jaredite history that he had just recently translated (Mosiah 28:11-19). Moreover, some of those reasons carry specific language contained within that history.
In his message to the people, Mosiah noted:
He to whom the kingdom doth rightly belong has declined, and will not take upon him the kingdom. And now if there should be another appointed in his stead, behold I fear there would rise contentions among you. And who knoweth but what my son, to whom the kingdom doth belong, should turn to be angry and draw away a part of this people after him, which would cause wars and contentions among you, which would be the cause of shedding much blood and perverting the way of the Lord, yea, and destroy the souls of many people. (Mosiah 29:6-7)
No such situation had been specifically detailed among the Nephites.* However, it was common among the Jaredites for brother to rebel against brother or father and draw away part of the people to wage war (Ether 7:4-5, 15-17; 8:2-3; 9:11-12; 10:3, 8-10, 14, 32; 11:4, 15-18). Moreover, the idea of “drawing away” supporters (Mosiah 29:7) is known in the Book of Mormon only from the Jaredite record (Ether 7:4, 15; 9:11; 10:32).
Mosiah stressed that the wickedness of King Noah had caused the people to come into bondage (Mosiah 29:18-19). However, this is also a common theme in the book of Ether. For example, at the time kingship was first established among the Jaredites, the brother of Jared warned that it would lead to captivity (Ether 6:22-23). During the history of the people, a number of kings were conquered by their own son or brother and made to serve in captivity (Ether 7:5, 7, 17; 8:3-4; 10:14-15, 30-31; 11:9, 18-19, 23; 13:23).
Another of Mosiah’s justifications for allowing the people to elect their judges was that “it is not common that the voice of the people desireth anything contrary to that which is right” (Mosiah 29:26). But he noted that “if the time comes that the voice of the people doth choose iniquity, then is the time that the judgments of God will come upon you; yea, then is the time he will visit you with great destruction even as he has hitherto visited this land” (Mosiah 29:27). Since the Nephites had not experienced such “great destruction” on “this land,” Mosiah must have had the destruction of the Jaredites in mind [assuming the fact that such details were not chronicled in the “lost 116 pages” portion of the large plates]. [John A. Tvedtnes, “King Mosiah and the Judgeship,” in FARMS Update, Number 140, in Insights, November 2000, p. 2]
Note* For a discussion on other factors involved in the abolishment of Nephite kingship, see Michael Hobby’s commentary on the Mulekite connection. While Tvedtnes comments that no previous division because of a kingship dispute among brothers had been specifically detailed among the Nephites, the reader should note that such a dispute over birthright and kingship might very well be implied in the story of Nephi versus Laman & Lemuel (see 1 Nephi 16:37-38; 2 Nephi 5:1-3, 6-9, 34). [Alan C. Miner, Personal Notes]
“I Desire That Ye Should Consider the Cause Which Ye Are Called to Consider for Ye Are Desirous to Have a King”
In the 29th chapter of Mosiah, we find a discourse by Mosiah on the problems associated with kingship. The people heed Mosiah’s warnings and change to a system of judges.
According to Robert Matthews, it is interesting that after the time of Moses, a period of judges was established (Deborah Samson, and so forth), but eventually the people of Israel desired to have a king, “like all the nations” (1 Samuel 8:4-5). Certain that such a course would lead to social and political trouble, Samuel the prophet-judge made a solemn protest concerning it. The Lord, however, allowed them an earthly king because they desired it--but not until they had been sufficiently warned through Samuel of the Lord’s displeasure (1 Samuel 8:6-22). [Robert J. Matthews, A Burning Light: The Life and Ministry of John the Baptist, p. 13]
Note* Although both Mosiah and Samuel spoke against kingship, it is interesting to see the differences in perspectives on the problems of kingship that each one brought forth. For the benefit of the reader, so that comparisons might be made between Mosiah’s words of warning on kingship (Mosiah 29:1-41) and Samuel’s words of warning (1 Samuel 8:6-22), the text of 1 Samuel is as follows:
But the thing displeased Samuel, when they said, Give us a king to judge us. And Samuel prayed unto the Lord.
And the Lord said unto Samuel, Hearken unto the voice of the people in all that they say unto thee: for they have not rejected thee, but they have rejected me, that I should not reign over them.
According to all the works which they have done since the day that I brought them up out of Egypt even unto this day, wherewith they have forsaken me, and served other gods, so do they also unto thee.
Now therefore hearken unto their voice: howbeit yet protest solemnly unto them, and shew them the manner of the king that shall reign over them.
And Samuel told all the words of the Lord unto the people that asked of him a king.
And he said, This will be the manner of the king that shall reign over you: He will take your sons, and appoint them for himself, for his chariots, and to be his horsemen; and some shall run before his chariots.
And he will appoint him captains over thousands, and captains over fifties; and will set them to ear his ground, and to reap his harvest, and to make his instruments of war, and instruments of his chariots.
And he will take your daughters to be confectionaries, and to be cooks, and to be bakers.
And he will take your fields, and your vineyards, and your olive-yards, even the best of them, and give them to his servants.
And he will take the tenth of your seed, and of your vineyards, and give to his officers, and to his servants.
And he will take your menservants, and your maidservants, and your goodliest young men, and your asses, and put them to his work.
He will take the tenth of your sheep: and ye shall be his servants.
And ye shall cry out in that day because of your king which ye shall have chosen you; and the Lord will not hear you in that day.
Nevertheless the people refused to obey the voice of Samuel; and they said, Nay; but we will have a king over us;
That we also may be like all the nations; and that our king may judge us, and go out before us, and fight our battles.
And Samuel heard all the words of the people, and he rehearsed them in the ears of the Lord.
And the Lord said to Samuel, Hearken unto their voice, and make them a king. And Samuel said unto the men of Israel, Go ye every man unto his city.
[Alan C. Miner, Personal Notes] [See the commentary on Ether 6:23]